24 Comments
User's avatar
Joe From the Bronx's avatar

There are many good proposals for court reform & it is proper to have hearings regarding various things. But, AOC's impeachment resolutions are fine as a messaging measure + at least for Thomas are correct on the merits [we can carp on the exact terms]. Impeachment is in place partially to deal with such over the top violations of good behavior. At least in theory.

WRDinDC's avatar

There's a tension in your comment here: is impeachment "in place partially to deal with such over the top violations of good behavior" or is it a mechanism that's "fine as a messaging measure"?

I think it's wrong when Republicans do their performative impeachments of Biden and Mayorkas. I also think AOC's performative, messaging impeachment is wrong.

Joe From the Bronx's avatar

It can be both. It is messaging because there is no real chance it will be successfully prosecuted. Unlike the "performative" impeachments cited, it is correct on the merits. I tried to go out of my way there & grant maybe Alito is a stretch. Thomas is not. His actions at this point are worthy of an impeachment process being carried out.

Greg Morrow's avatar

The articles of impeachment may be futile in terms of actual political action, but they are useful in a performative way -- they move the Overton window. If Democrats only ever mention what's possible or practical, while Republicans are vocal about what they want, what is possible can only move in the Republican direction. By saying that she's not going to quietly acquiesce to corruption, AOC is making clear that corruption is a valid topic that something can be done about.

Peter Gerdes's avatar

Except it's not just about whose policies are favored it's about fundamental threats to the rule of law.

Now if Trump wants to do something and SCOTUS says he can't we've fucking paved the path for him to threaten to impeach justices in response and made it easier for him to say the court is illegitimate and ignore it Jackson style.

The cost of constantly calling the court illegitimate is that someone might believe you. Or that they won't believe that this time things are really different when Trump appoints some judge Cannon style justice.

--

And yah, it's unfair but that's the nature of being the good guy -- you have to worry about consequences the other guy won't.

Glen Anderson's avatar

Peter, I'm a late subscriber to Steve's Substack, and I'm slowly working backwards on his articles. Having prefaced that, what would be your thoughts on "constantly calling the court illegitimate" now that trump has called for a judge to be impeached as well as

ignored the court?

Peter Gerdes's avatar

It's all the more important to stand up for the legitimacy of the court and against Trump's attempts to ignore court rulings. There is a huge difference between not agreeing with what the court says and defying it and I think when we call the court illegitimate -- not merely wrong -- we make it a bit easier to excuse crossing that line.

Basically it comes down to this, Trump is a fundamental threat to our system of democratic government and the rule of law and the courts are the only institution that is likely to be able to do anything to restrain him. Now you might wish SCOTUS and the courts had done more in the past or were doing more now but that's not the choice we have -- we have the choice between calling the court illegitimate and weakening them in any conflict with the executive or making it clear that it's a foundational principle that you don't get to ignore the court merely because you disagree.

Think of it this way. It's a war. We might wish the court was a clear ally but if we atrack them because they aren't as strong an ally as we might wish we just weaken ourselves and the court and play into Trump's hand. The more we call the court illegitimate the more he can excuse ignoring what they say.

Remember that there are lots of Americans who have very different views of the court than we do and are given to having the opposite criticisms of their deciscions. If they don't see us modeling the principle that you must respect court decisions as legitimate even when you strongly disagree why would they think that Trump has any obligation to respect the deciscions they/he disagrees with?

---

And regarding SCOTUS, regardless of justice politics they all tend to be very protective of the perogatives of the court. Nothing like arresting a judge to send the signal "it could be you next." So I have hope.

Glen Anderson's avatar

Thank you for taking the time to answer and explain why I'm in agreement with you. I'll only add, as a "rookie" at 68, retired with the time now to try to educate my limited knowledge of how the tiers of courts work and make a stab atunderstanding the complicated world of the judicial system. It is still in my personal opinion that Thomas should have excused himself from trump's immunity plea. Perhaps Alito as well, but I don't feel he was as "guilty" of obvious bias as Thomas appeared to be.

It's just unbelievably disheartening to know that we're teaching a generation of younger individuals who are witnessing the POTUS, hired into the most powerful office in the world, continuously committing crimes after crimes and receiving no punishment, only fines that the average American could not imagine accumulating. How many prisoners are learning from this point in history, how many children, how many people down on their luck and would normally never think about committing a crime, let alone the number of crimes trump has, both civil and criminal. We have a great system, compared to many countries, but man, when it fucks up, it does it royally. IMHO I can't believe we're not ransacking the capital after the immunity given to that set of criminals. With an added kick in the nuts of perhaps paying restitutions. It's just too much some days to even read the daily news. I disliked Nixon, but this one? No words. Again, thank you, I appreciate your time and information.

Frank Canzolino's avatar

The Federal Government says it was an assassination attempt, why are your elect ant to do the same?

M. Mechanick's avatar

While a bit tangential, and it is unlikely that DOJ/Jack Smith would seek reconsideration of the immunity ruling (and probably even less likely in light of today's other news), a couple of questions relating to the scope of the immunity ruling. First of all, is it possible in the event of impeachment and conviction by the Congress for high crimes and misdemeanors involving official acts of the President, would that be sufficient to overcome the determination of absolute immunity for subsequent prosecution of those crimes or would absolute immunity for official acts continue to exist. Secondly, while it has been posited that, as an extreme example, while immunity would shield the President for any crimes arising from official acts, if an underling carries out an order for which the President is shielded, Presidential immunity should not flow down to that underling as well. I can certainly imagine defense counsel aggressively trying to argue that a criminal act committed by an underling in direct response to a Presidential order involving the exercise of an official act should shield the underling as well. Your thoughts on both questions.

Susan Linehan's avatar

Thank you for RFK's sadly ironic comments. I'll bet the most responses you will get to day are

"WTF will SCOTUS do with Cannon. And when?"

Margaret Saleeby's avatar

Thanks for including Bobby Kennedy’s speech! I wish it would resonate with the masses today. However, our attention spans have been trained by social media not to tolerate much more that quick clips of information regardless of their reliability. Consequently for large segments of the population we no longer are a nation that truly has a common set of values. Instead we sadly are a nation of individuals being led by the algorithms governing what they see on their screens.

Glen Anderson's avatar

Hear,hear. We're also a nation of too many individuals who failed at history's lessons.

Patricia Jaeger's avatar

"Missouri’s (preposterous) effort to use the Court’s “original jurisdiction” to halt further proceedings in the New York state criminal fraud case against former President Trump." Both current MO Senators, Schmitt and Hawley) were MO AGs and both got publicity, and later elected to the Senate, by filing "preposterous" lawsuits that MO taxpayers had to pay for. Hawley also violated MO sunset laws and was hit with a $250,000 fine that MO taxpayers will have to pay. Our current AG, Bailey is the doofus who filed the NY state lawsuit which again, we in MO will have to pay for. Republican party rule is very costly in terms of gun safety, education, abortion, and in frivolous lawsuits that only benefit the AG.

Mike Godwin's avatar

In the RFK speech to the Cleveland City Club, you include this sentence: "The question is now what programs we should seek to enact." In context, I think that "now" is a "not."

Peter Gerdes's avatar

So does AOC and those applauding her move really believe Trump presents an existential threat to our republic like they claim or not?

If they do then attacking the court as illegitimate or bringing articles of impeachment is the last thing they should be doing. By all means, disagree with the deciscions -- I know I think they made some big blunders this term because they are biased humans -- but when it comes down to it in a second Trump term it surely makes things worse if he can point to the left and AOC when he wants to ignore a court ruling.

It's hard to convince the public it's unthinkable to ignore what the court says when you've been calling it illegitimate. And it's going to be hard to make the case about what's so wrong when Trump appoints justice Cannon when we've used maximalist language in critisizing the court as it is.

Williamparker's avatar

The discussion on petitions for rehearing shows how legal procedures can provide another opportunity to review a disputed decision. Clear access to case information can help readers follow filings, rulings, and later developments with greater context. For those researching related matters https://sumnercountycourt.org can provide a useful starting point for reviewing public case information. Posts like this are helpful for highlighting how court processes can affect disputes after an initial decision.