A bill being rushed through the lame-duck Senate pairs overdue grid reforms with sharp limits on judicial review. Its fate should be left to the next Congress.
The basic substantive BAAJA problem is that courts should have almost no role in stopping construction at all. They are just a tool for rich people and NIMBY's to stop societal progress. So you have to cut them out. The old model means a stagnant America.
And the procedural problem is that this is the only time we'll have to do this. It's do it now or we condemn America to long term societal decline as we never reform our building process or get BS environmental objections out of the way, not now or we do it later. The new Congress is full of green types who want to kill this and even if they passed something POTUS might veto it.
Sometimes judicial review is an impediment to state capacity and a tool of moneyed interests. This is one of those times.
Good to hear you are on the board of Earthjustice, and thanks for the very thorough review of the BAAJA.
The "rush" is the key: handing over what is in the final analysis veto power to oligarchic interests over a deliberative public process that may stall their plans.
Even the "best" part of the bill, rationalizing the transmission lines, strikes me as simply a preliminary move for placing data centers everywhere. That's why the electricity is "needed" in the first place.
The owners of these vast enterprises get concrete concessions from this bill; alternative futures get vague promises.
Finally note the support of Democrats like Sheldon Whitehouse, indicating how badly we need an actual opposition in Congress. We may actually get than come January 3rd. That's why they're passing this bill now.
Actually I and many of your fellow citizens also need cheaper electricity (and hell, the services provided by data centers). Just because you have the money to pay extra does not mean the rest of us want to
You've made a lot of assumptions, and I don't believe it will play out as you're expecting. Bills of this type are almost always extractive in both intent and effect: the only thing they actually reduce is public control.
But I was thinking of the struggle in North Dakota against the pipeline they were running across Native lands (from the Canadian coal tar sands.) As with all reductionist approaches that may be too narrow.
But still, I would bear in mind whose interests are being served--who really has access to our politicians to write these bills. Often it is solely industry lobbyists. This is why no one in the general public has any money to spare!
Every sign points to the BAAJA being another giveaway.
For every defender of the filibuster, this bill and this process shows they are actually full of it. A manager's amendment that never even got debated in committed gets appended to a pre-existing unrelated bill somehow does not require more debate? How can that be if the reasons the filibuster must exist are pure? It would be so much better to limit the filibuster, proceed with regular order, and pass things in small but digestible bills. Let each section here stand up or down on its own.
The environmental movement is committed to a degrowth strategy that will make Americans poorer, especially those at the bottom of the income scale, while failing to solve the problem of climate change.
I would rather trust a future Congress to fix any problems and loopholes in this bill than do nothing.
One final point, if I may: Democratic Senators like Whitehouse and Heinrich will have settled their quid pro quos with their rich benefactors and will be free to grandstand come January 3rd.
“earlier this year, a federal judge in Maryland blocked the conversion of a warehouse into an ICE detention center on NEPA grounds”
I am no fan of what this administration is doing with ICE but to me the environmental protection act being used as a pretext to block an immigration detention center because the complainants have a political problem with what it's been used for sounds exactly like NEPA is broken as hell.
I see the change in the listing order of the Opinions in the Court's website (but not of "Opinions Related to Orders") didn't quite make the miscellany or trivia this week... there were more important things to say.
I appreciate this write up. After reading the NY Times Editorial Board article about this last week—where they implored the dems to pass this law quickly—I am happy to see the other side presented here.
It seems the dems feel obligated to make it "look" like they're working on affordability, which makes this bill low hanging fruit for passage. The last thing we should be doing with the current President is removing accountability.
CCL acknowledges that parts of the bill will benefit some fossil fuel projects (which is why it has Republican support) but they conclude that, over all, the bill is a clear plus for speeding up GHG reduction by speeding up permitting which is necessary for quicker electrification. CCL has concluded that our current President will be around for over two more years and, in their judgment, the incoming new "improved" Congress will not be able to pass a "better bill."
Right, that's what nearly 100% of the GOP supports it, and a majority of Democratic Senators are against it, because it's such a great bill for the environment.
It's misleading to say the bill has had no Senate hearings as evidence that it hasn't been long debated in public. Almost every major section of BAAJA builds on House-passed or introduced legislation—especially the NEPA sections that went through a big committee process in House Natural Resources. The one exception is the transmission section as Republicans in Energy and Commerce didn't consider transmission legislation, but that builds on the Senate ENR-passed EPRA bill from the 118th Congress. A good list of examples is here, to which you could add the several House-passed nuclear bills added in the manager's amendment:
It's very disturbing to me to see that Sheldon Whitehouse is supporting This bill, suggesting that Trump will not be able to interfere with clean energy infrastructure building. I don't believe that for a minute. If you can please call your senators.
I think the practical problem with "pushing pause on BAAJA" is that in this context there is really no difference between "pause" and "never."
'Never' would be preferable, in this case.
The mental gymnastics required to justify handing this administration even a lick more executive power are mind-boggling.
It’s a bill created without seeing a Dem majority in the near future.
Thank you!
The basic substantive BAAJA problem is that courts should have almost no role in stopping construction at all. They are just a tool for rich people and NIMBY's to stop societal progress. So you have to cut them out. The old model means a stagnant America.
And the procedural problem is that this is the only time we'll have to do this. It's do it now or we condemn America to long term societal decline as we never reform our building process or get BS environmental objections out of the way, not now or we do it later. The new Congress is full of green types who want to kill this and even if they passed something POTUS might veto it.
Sometimes judicial review is an impediment to state capacity and a tool of moneyed interests. This is one of those times.
Good to hear you are on the board of Earthjustice, and thanks for the very thorough review of the BAAJA.
The "rush" is the key: handing over what is in the final analysis veto power to oligarchic interests over a deliberative public process that may stall their plans.
Even the "best" part of the bill, rationalizing the transmission lines, strikes me as simply a preliminary move for placing data centers everywhere. That's why the electricity is "needed" in the first place.
The owners of these vast enterprises get concrete concessions from this bill; alternative futures get vague promises.
Finally note the support of Democrats like Sheldon Whitehouse, indicating how badly we need an actual opposition in Congress. We may actually get than come January 3rd. That's why they're passing this bill now.
Actually I and many of your fellow citizens also need cheaper electricity (and hell, the services provided by data centers). Just because you have the money to pay extra does not mean the rest of us want to
You've made a lot of assumptions, and I don't believe it will play out as you're expecting. Bills of this type are almost always extractive in both intent and effect: the only thing they actually reduce is public control.
Endless lawsuits from moneyed up special interest groups is not “public control”
Our legal system is incredibly inefficient.
But I was thinking of the struggle in North Dakota against the pipeline they were running across Native lands (from the Canadian coal tar sands.) As with all reductionist approaches that may be too narrow.
But still, I would bear in mind whose interests are being served--who really has access to our politicians to write these bills. Often it is solely industry lobbyists. This is why no one in the general public has any money to spare!
Every sign points to the BAAJA being another giveaway.
For every defender of the filibuster, this bill and this process shows they are actually full of it. A manager's amendment that never even got debated in committed gets appended to a pre-existing unrelated bill somehow does not require more debate? How can that be if the reasons the filibuster must exist are pure? It would be so much better to limit the filibuster, proceed with regular order, and pass things in small but digestible bills. Let each section here stand up or down on its own.
The environmental movement is committed to a degrowth strategy that will make Americans poorer, especially those at the bottom of the income scale, while failing to solve the problem of climate change.
I would rather trust a future Congress to fix any problems and loopholes in this bill than do nothing.
One final point, if I may: Democratic Senators like Whitehouse and Heinrich will have settled their quid pro quos with their rich benefactors and will be free to grandstand come January 3rd.
“earlier this year, a federal judge in Maryland blocked the conversion of a warehouse into an ICE detention center on NEPA grounds”
I am no fan of what this administration is doing with ICE but to me the environmental protection act being used as a pretext to block an immigration detention center because the complainants have a political problem with what it's been used for sounds exactly like NEPA is broken as hell.
I see the change in the listing order of the Opinions in the Court's website (but not of "Opinions Related to Orders") didn't quite make the miscellany or trivia this week... there were more important things to say.
I appreciate this write up. After reading the NY Times Editorial Board article about this last week—where they implored the dems to pass this law quickly—I am happy to see the other side presented here.
It seems the dems feel obligated to make it "look" like they're working on affordability, which makes this bill low hanging fruit for passage. The last thing we should be doing with the current President is removing accountability.
Citizens' Climate Lobby, after serious analysis, has endorsed BAAJA, with the managers amendment [https://static.prod01.ue1.p.pcomm.net/cclobby/content/resources/BAAJA%20Fact%20Sheet.pdf].
CCL acknowledges that parts of the bill will benefit some fossil fuel projects (which is why it has Republican support) but they conclude that, over all, the bill is a clear plus for speeding up GHG reduction by speeding up permitting which is necessary for quicker electrification. CCL has concluded that our current President will be around for over two more years and, in their judgment, the incoming new "improved" Congress will not be able to pass a "better bill."
Bipartisan Policy Center "Explainer":
https://bipartisanpolicy.org/explainer/explaining-the-senate-permitting-bill-the-bipartisan-american-affordability-and-jobs-act/ .
Disappointing post - this would open the door to immense green infrastructure investment if democrats win in 2028.
Right, that's what nearly 100% of the GOP supports it, and a majority of Democratic Senators are against it, because it's such a great bill for the environment.
It's misleading to say the bill has had no Senate hearings as evidence that it hasn't been long debated in public. Almost every major section of BAAJA builds on House-passed or introduced legislation—especially the NEPA sections that went through a big committee process in House Natural Resources. The one exception is the transmission section as Republicans in Energy and Commerce didn't consider transmission legislation, but that builds on the Senate ENR-passed EPRA bill from the 118th Congress. A good list of examples is here, to which you could add the several House-passed nuclear bills added in the manager's amendment:
https://x.com/m1chellehung/status/2118516669081624875
It's very disturbing to me to see that Sheldon Whitehouse is supporting This bill, suggesting that Trump will not be able to interfere with clean energy infrastructure building. I don't believe that for a minute. If you can please call your senators.
Trump will be gone. We want legislation that can lay the basis for great things starting now and going on into the future.
Just posting this here for another take on the BAAJA bill. Via Ezra Klein at the NYT (gift link) https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/15/opinion/democrats-permitting-reform-bill-affordability.html?unlocked_article_code=1.Q1E.-cqk.4SHBYUL75wW5&smid=url-share