Justice Alito‘s book purports to answer the Court’s critics—by rebutting a caricature and ignoring the ways in which his own behavior contradicts his claims.
Alito's insistence that the Court is apolitical and not doing anything untoward reminds me of Senator Larry Craig's insistence that he wasn't soliciting sex from men in bathrooms.
Both men are just too upstanding for such accusations.
If honesty means integrity, these sorts exist with their thinking about things in separate compartments that they never compare with each other. They're personalities are too fragmented to arrive at anything resembling jurisprudence.
From my reading of Alito's opinions, he (along with Thomas) never learned to distinguish between their desires and what was actually written. Kavanaugh is a close third. (All three strike me as mediocrities.)
Agreed. I am a contemporary of Alito and Thomas … and I cannot help but remember that when we were children in the 1950s, NONE of us - an African-American, a Southern Italian-American (and both are Catholics) and Jewish me - were considered Caucasian. Now two-thirds of us seem to want to prop up a new, “wise” WASP minority rule. Why? Because in our youth we were so warmly accepted?
By my reading of it, the cornucopia of the post-war period began to dry up by the mid-sixties. (The vast treasure expended on the Vietnam War was sort of a factor, but there were structural issues afoot as well.)
By the early seventies--the time of soon-to-be Justice Lewis Powell's well-known call-to-arms--capital had begun actively planning both an exodus (to China,) and among its more radical elements, a determined counterrevolution (taking the 60's as they saw it, i.e. revolution).
There was ideological and some institutional continuity with the revolt of a segment of the wealthy against Roosevelt's New Deal in the 1930's. But this counterrevolution wasn't a "popular" choice. Rather, racist, xenophobic and reactionary religious elements of the electorate were mobilized to produce either paralysis or a slim victory. The first outcome saw the counterrevolution advance through the judiciary; in the second, through the executive, with Congress effectively sidelined. From my study, this was a deliberate strategy.
But the Supreme Court has long been the avant garde of this American fascism--they only need five votes, not millions.
The skewed treatment of balance-of-equities in favor of the government is the most consistent problem these days in shadow docket rulings. Hand in hand with that is the unwarranted deprecation of irremediable harm to the opposing litigants.
—Is Donald Trump in mental decline, do you think? Has he lost his fastball?
The poster child for the Court’s disregard for the balance of equities is its order in DVD vs DHS. Sending people to Equitorial Guinea where the NYT has documented hooding and torture of deportees should be a clear and easy show of risk of irreparable harm vs the DHS claim that denial of its requested relief will impact “logistics” of deportation flights.
The Court majority owns this problem because it kept taking cases (and continues to do so.) Like kids on 10/31, walking up to doors expecting candy, those who get what they want when they request emergency relief will keep asking for that relief.
I haven't read Chapter 8 or its antecedents, but Alito is someone about whom I keep in mind: "Listen carefully to what they are accusing you of. It's probably what they're up to."
It may also be relevant to make note of the remarks Alito made to CBS news this past weekend. According to Heather Cox Richardson, he told Jan Crawford that the distinction between the Supreme Court case recognizing the right to gay marriage and Roe v. Wade is that the former won't be overturned because of widespread social reliance upon it by people making important life decisions, whereas the latter recognized a mostly "abstract" right that had impact mainly on people's ideas. So... Alito is a guy who, if we are believe him, thinks the process of having and raising a baby is an abstract proposition compared to the choice whether to enter into a marriage contract. Taken at his own word, Alito has the reasoning ability of a gnat and no grip on reality at all. His "jurisprudence" consists of thinly rationalized prejudices grounded in authoritarian instincts and disregard for law and facts.
Not to mention his preference for Church “law” vs. rule of law and precedent (notwithstanding his claims otherwise before Congress confirmation hearings.
The volume, of course, is entirely under the justices’ control. A bit more deference to the (often extensive) fact-finding of the trial courts and a willingness to occasionally tell Trump his complaint doesn’t merit their attention would be a good place to start.
Alito is an intellectually dishonest ideologue. With the comfort of four or five reactionary justices by his side, he’s not about to pass up the opportunity to right what he perceives are wrongs, regardless of the means. That includes lying.
Mr. Sharp, I am a liberal Democrat living my retirement in Massachusetts. For 40 years, I was a lawyer partner of Harriet Miers (the correct spelling of her last name). Although I most always disagreed with her political beliefs and positions, I am 100% convinced that she was and is a staunch supporter of American democracy, the Constitution, and the rule of law. The Harriet Miers I know is a kind and decent person. And I believe she is just as appalled by all things Trump as I am, and as I think you are, too. I believe she would have been a much better Supreme Court Justice than either Alito or Thomas.
Mr. Beatty, I’m sure Harriet Myers is a lovely person - and certainly no Bork - but back then (just 21 years ago!), it was considered “inappropriate” that a president’s personal lawyer be nominated for associate justice. And no doubt she was a much better choice than Alito. But my (blunted) point is that Alito was a disastrous second choice after an ill-considered first.
She did not want that job. But she has known George Bush since before he was governor of Texas. Bush was opposed to the state lottery, but the legislature passed it with veto-proof majority. He picked Harriet to head the lottery commission. He took her to DC to be his personal presidential secretary. When Bush approached her about his plan to nominate her she wasn’t excited, but one doesn’t say no when the president wants to appoint you. Thus her deer-in-the-headlights performance. Although she never said so, I think she was relieved that she didn’t get the position.
Do you really want Alito to defend his reasoning in case outcomes? If he does he will merely do what he does in writing up the decisions of the court--make up the most outlandish "what ifs" as his argument to reach whatever conclusion he likes. I have always wondered how the seemingly smarter members of the court can go along with it every time he pulls that phrase outl
This is why I subscribe to you. Sometimes I get lost in the minutia of the court decisions that you do an excellent job of explaining to an everyday person like me what they mean thank you.
Even without the many academic arguments Prof. Vladeck makes here, the man on the street is gradually becoming suspicious of the "emergency" docket -- because, increasingly, it seems that the only emergency is the impatience of our President to have his orders validated. The right-vs-left skew in these decisions is quickly eroding (further) Court legitimacy.
sounds about right for his level of “scholarship.”
Highly recommend following the link to the Youtube video for an explanation of the way the Shadow Docket is now being used/abused. Thank you.
Alito's insistence that the Court is apolitical and not doing anything untoward reminds me of Senator Larry Craig's insistence that he wasn't soliciting sex from men in bathrooms.
Both men are just too upstanding for such accusations.
Hey, they take a wide stance on verity!
If honesty means integrity, these sorts exist with their thinking about things in separate compartments that they never compare with each other. They're personalities are too fragmented to arrive at anything resembling jurisprudence.
From my reading of Alito's opinions, he (along with Thomas) never learned to distinguish between their desires and what was actually written. Kavanaugh is a close third. (All three strike me as mediocrities.)
Agreed. I am a contemporary of Alito and Thomas … and I cannot help but remember that when we were children in the 1950s, NONE of us - an African-American, a Southern Italian-American (and both are Catholics) and Jewish me - were considered Caucasian. Now two-thirds of us seem to want to prop up a new, “wise” WASP minority rule. Why? Because in our youth we were so warmly accepted?
By my reading of it, the cornucopia of the post-war period began to dry up by the mid-sixties. (The vast treasure expended on the Vietnam War was sort of a factor, but there were structural issues afoot as well.)
By the early seventies--the time of soon-to-be Justice Lewis Powell's well-known call-to-arms--capital had begun actively planning both an exodus (to China,) and among its more radical elements, a determined counterrevolution (taking the 60's as they saw it, i.e. revolution).
There was ideological and some institutional continuity with the revolt of a segment of the wealthy against Roosevelt's New Deal in the 1930's. But this counterrevolution wasn't a "popular" choice. Rather, racist, xenophobic and reactionary religious elements of the electorate were mobilized to produce either paralysis or a slim victory. The first outcome saw the counterrevolution advance through the judiciary; in the second, through the executive, with Congress effectively sidelined. From my study, this was a deliberate strategy.
But the Supreme Court has long been the avant garde of this American fascism--they only need five votes, not millions.
End lifetime appointments and set a mandatory retirement age of 65.
The skewed treatment of balance-of-equities in favor of the government is the most consistent problem these days in shadow docket rulings. Hand in hand with that is the unwarranted deprecation of irremediable harm to the opposing litigants.
—Is Donald Trump in mental decline, do you think? Has he lost his fastball?
He lost both of 'em a ways back.
"Hand in hand with that is the unwarranted deprecation of irremediable harm to the opposing litigants." Yes.
The poster child for the Court’s disregard for the balance of equities is its order in DVD vs DHS. Sending people to Equitorial Guinea where the NYT has documented hooding and torture of deportees should be a clear and easy show of risk of irreparable harm vs the DHS claim that denial of its requested relief will impact “logistics” of deportation flights.
Makes one wonder how well his brain is functioning in general . . .
The Court majority owns this problem because it kept taking cases (and continues to do so.) Like kids on 10/31, walking up to doors expecting candy, those who get what they want when they request emergency relief will keep asking for that relief.
👏👏👏 Could not agree more
I haven't read Chapter 8 or its antecedents, but Alito is someone about whom I keep in mind: "Listen carefully to what they are accusing you of. It's probably what they're up to."
It may also be relevant to make note of the remarks Alito made to CBS news this past weekend. According to Heather Cox Richardson, he told Jan Crawford that the distinction between the Supreme Court case recognizing the right to gay marriage and Roe v. Wade is that the former won't be overturned because of widespread social reliance upon it by people making important life decisions, whereas the latter recognized a mostly "abstract" right that had impact mainly on people's ideas. So... Alito is a guy who, if we are believe him, thinks the process of having and raising a baby is an abstract proposition compared to the choice whether to enter into a marriage contract. Taken at his own word, Alito has the reasoning ability of a gnat and no grip on reality at all. His "jurisprudence" consists of thinly rationalized prejudices grounded in authoritarian instincts and disregard for law and facts.
Not to mention his preference for Church “law” vs. rule of law and precedent (notwithstanding his claims otherwise before Congress confirmation hearings.
The volume, of course, is entirely under the justices’ control. A bit more deference to the (often extensive) fact-finding of the trial courts and a willingness to occasionally tell Trump his complaint doesn’t merit their attention would be a good place to start.
Alito is an intellectually dishonest ideologue. With the comfort of four or five reactionary justices by his side, he’s not about to pass up the opportunity to right what he perceives are wrongs, regardless of the means. That includes lying.
And let’s praise his victory as a second choice … after Harriet Myers.
And let's not forget that even as he spoke at some length about why he could not vote for Roberts, Obama voted for Alito's confirmation.
Perhaps under the assumption that federal judges would tell the truth before Congress. How 20th Century silly!
Mr. Sharp, I am a liberal Democrat living my retirement in Massachusetts. For 40 years, I was a lawyer partner of Harriet Miers (the correct spelling of her last name). Although I most always disagreed with her political beliefs and positions, I am 100% convinced that she was and is a staunch supporter of American democracy, the Constitution, and the rule of law. The Harriet Miers I know is a kind and decent person. And I believe she is just as appalled by all things Trump as I am, and as I think you are, too. I believe she would have been a much better Supreme Court Justice than either Alito or Thomas.
Mr. Beatty, I’m sure Harriet Myers is a lovely person - and certainly no Bork - but back then (just 21 years ago!), it was considered “inappropriate” that a president’s personal lawyer be nominated for associate justice. And no doubt she was a much better choice than Alito. But my (blunted) point is that Alito was a disastrous second choice after an ill-considered first.
She did not want that job. But she has known George Bush since before he was governor of Texas. Bush was opposed to the state lottery, but the legislature passed it with veto-proof majority. He picked Harriet to head the lottery commission. He took her to DC to be his personal presidential secretary. When Bush approached her about his plan to nominate her she wasn’t excited, but one doesn’t say no when the president wants to appoint you. Thus her deer-in-the-headlights performance. Although she never said so, I think she was relieved that she didn’t get the position.
Do you really want Alito to defend his reasoning in case outcomes? If he does he will merely do what he does in writing up the decisions of the court--make up the most outlandish "what ifs" as his argument to reach whatever conclusion he likes. I have always wondered how the seemingly smarter members of the court can go along with it every time he pulls that phrase outl
More like a cabal than a court.
SC: The law is not on our side. The facts are not on our side. Fortunately, we have the Shadow Docket. So ordered!
This is why I subscribe to you. Sometimes I get lost in the minutia of the court decisions that you do an excellent job of explaining to an everyday person like me what they mean thank you.
Even without the many academic arguments Prof. Vladeck makes here, the man on the street is gradually becoming suspicious of the "emergency" docket -- because, increasingly, it seems that the only emergency is the impatience of our President to have his orders validated. The right-vs-left skew in these decisions is quickly eroding (further) Court legitimacy.